I received this question in a comment on my “
” blog post in August.
How could I talk about investments in relation to the poor
, who can’t afford anything anyway?
Well, maybe I write a little too pointedly here sometimes. But
isn't it sometimes necessary to draw attention to
how to turn things around?
First, I’d like to revisit the terminology “First World” or “Third World”
.
I believe it’s a mistake to speak of different worlds.
As long as we in the affluent world speak of the “Third World,”
we’re suggesting to ourselves that there is a world with which we are not
connected and that what happens there has no impact
on us.
To me, this applies just as much to the term “nature conservation.” Today, we use this term
in a way that implies humans are not part of nature.
That is why we always seem to realize too late that
events in the so-called Third World, or in nature,
can indeed have a direct impact on us.
So what happens when we talk about a world of the rich and the poor
? Is it easy, then, for a “poor” person to move into the world of the rich
? My thesis is that we program the manifestation
of this difference.
Can you feel the difference when we clearly state that there is only one
world, in which some have chosen to be rich and others
poor? Well, perhaps you’re already feeling so much
resistance that you can’t really sense it. But perhaps
we can agree that if there is only one world,
then it should be easier to switch “sides”—that is, levels of prosperity—
than it would be if there were different worlds.
Now, regarding the accusation that poor people couldn’t possibly buy stocks
because they have no money. It is in the nature of
human beings—as living creatures—not to focus on
long-term planning when under the stress of survival. But let’s assume for a moment that a
“poor person” (I ask once again for your indulgence regarding this
oversimplification) could save up 50 euros. What do
we think their thoughts would be on how to use that money? To invest it wisely
so it grows and secures their future?
Are these their first thoughts? Usually not.
I believe—at least based on my many years of experience
in financial counseling—that it’s unfortunately the norm for people to be willing to
work for 45 years for money, but not to take 45 minutes a month
to think about money.
In my book, I presented a 7-point success program,
, whose first point is: Decision!
And in this world we live in, there are people who have
decided to take personal responsibility, and others who often work extremely
hard and live a meager life, yet still haven’t
decided to take personal responsibility for addressing the issue of money.
“Addressing” here means understanding how money works,
learning to evaluate investments, etc.
Now I’m constantly confronted with conspiracy theories—
—that politicians don’t actually want everyone to become independent. Once again,
—another good reason to stay in my “own little world.”
I don't believe that. I can even propose a different theory.
Could there perhaps be a conspiracy among the poor? Just give us enough
to eat, and then we won't need to further our education or
take on responsibility. Perhaps you'll realize that this
isn't just about the so-called poor. Ultimately, it's about everyone
who thinks someone else is responsible and should fix things.
Prof. Muhammad Yunus, who has helped many poor people in your situation
, was only able to achieve this because he got everyone—even beggars
—to take responsibility and
actively participate in changing their behavior
by adopting a different mindset. And how did he get started? Things always went wrong
because, in the beginning, he had only given money and had not
fostered personal responsibility.
Karl Heinz Böhm learned that many of his donations initially went to waste
because people weren't used to taking responsibility
for ensuring that a new well didn't silt up again.
Our system supports many who are dependent or in need, but
too few in getting out of that need. Is this a conspiracy by the poor,
that they only want help when they’re in need? I don’t believe in conspiracies on either
side. Rather, I believe in people’s weakness
—their tendency to take the easy path, the familiar path,
no matter how hard it is. Modern brain research confirms this.
The mind is stronger than matter; faith can move mountains
and where there’s a will, there’s a way. This isn’t new, but it’s consistently overlooked
. Let everyone examine what they believe in.
Those who believe in different worlds will “experience” them.
Those who think help is only possible in times of need, rather than emerging from need,
will create more hardship.
That is why the poor are getting poorer and the rich are getting richer—
—in the very same world.
Today is Sunday.
Do you have some time for yourself and new ideas today?
Sincerely,
Wolfgang Georg Sonnenburg
Winning for Life
_______